espritfollet:
This is a map of Asia. North Americans, you may notice this map is not solely comprised of Japan, Korea, China and Thailand. People in the UK, you may notice India is not a continent. That is, if those of you who generalize entire continents can even pinpoint India on a map.
Indians are Asian, gasp! And not all brown skinned people are Indian, also, gasp! There are an alarming amount of people, of all ages, from all backgrounds, who seem to be unable to process this.
I’m ethnically Asian. Since Asia is an extremely large continent, I could be from any number of countries. I am neither from India, China, Korea, Japan or Pakistan, yet not so surprisingly, I am still Asian.
Yes, there are commonalities across regions, through the conflation of cultures, colonialism, globalization, transnationalism and movement of diasporas. Sometimes these are all the same thing. Rickshaws, rice and curry can be found across the continent.
But let’s not overgeneralize. You can also find Buddhists, Catholics, Muslims and Hindus across Asia. Cantonese Speaking Chinese Muslims! English Speaking Indian Jews!
No, we are not all the same. Orientalism? (Please look up Edward Said for basic concepts) No thank you.
So let’s not use umbrella terms, regarding Asians as a monolith while simultaneously denying the regional identity of millions of people- and how about we also not engage in xenophobia?
Are you someone that thinks this way? Shame on you! You should perhaps invest in buying a map, and take a look at what countries are you know, where.
Geography, people. It’s important.
Holy mother it’s been years and I love all the commentary. I’ve learned a lot a lot since this original post and I can break down how stupid conflating all of us is down to DNA. ~ancient- DNA and not so ancient. Because we’re, er, all the same and also not, I will follow up at some point with admixtures / flow, steppe warriors, science, science, history, transnational, migration, everyone breeding things. Mind blowing things.
That said, the way we look now, is quite a recent development; over the last 400 years. Lines blurring in genetics but that said, current society and years of diasporas forming means that it’s time we start reexamining identities and racial paradigms, all over again.
Tldr I will write some long thing about denisovans stuff or y’all should peruse Razib Khan’s blog, twitter and Goodreads for intros to genetics (and history etc). Keep in mind that his very early posts are quite typical internalized, but watching his perspective shift with age and learning, curious thing.
http://www.razib.com/wordpress/ also at
unz review, gnxp